Santa Fe Sword Murder: Kiara McCulley Homicide Interrogation

weapon—a sword—immediately set this case apart from other local homicides. As officers arrived at the scene, they quickly identified a primary suspect: Kiara McCulley, a 19-year-old woman who lived on the property with her fiancé, Isaac Apodaca. Kiara was calm, cooperative, and showed no signs of resistance when taken into custody. However, what unfolded in the hours that followed would raise unsettling questions about her mental state, motive, and who else might have been involved.

In the full, uncut police interrogation video, Kiara is questioned by homicide detectives—and at one point, her mother is brought into the room, leading to emotional and contradictory statements. This interrogation, now available for public viewing, reveals the raw tension, confusion, and psychology of someone accused of a barbaric act. But was she acting alone? Or was this a murder fueled by manipulation and external influence?

CRIME SCENE DISCOVERY AND INITIAL POLICE RESPONSE

Santa Fe police officers were dispatched to the scene after receiving a 911 call reporting a woman who was possibly dead. Upon entering the detached garage on the property, officers discovered Grace Jennings’ body on the floor. She had suffered deep cuts, with injuries so severe that officers described the scene as resembling an attempted decapitation. A sword was found nearby.

The brutal nature of the injuries quickly led investigators to believe this was not a random or accidental death—it was a targeted, intentional killing.

McCulley was located near the scene and was immediately detained for questioning. Her demeanor was described as calm but emotionally disconnected. Officers noted that her clothing had what appeared to be blood stains, and preliminary testing confirmed the presence of blood.

Police quickly secured the crime scene, collected the sword as evidence, and transported McCulley to the Santa Fe Police Department for interrogation.

INTERROGATION VIDEO: FULL, UNCUT, AND RAW EMOTION

The full-length interrogation of Kiara McCulley is one of the most compelling and disturbing videos of its kind. The footage begins with Kiara alone in the interview room, quiet and withdrawn. When detectives enter, the tone is initially casual and calm, but it escalates as inconsistencies in her story begin to surface.

Kiara claims she doesn’t remember much from the night of the killing. She says she “blacked out” and only remembers seeing blood and the sword on the floor. Detectives press her with timelines, ask about her relationship with Grace Jennings, and attempt to uncover motive.

When McCulley’s mother is brought into the room, her emotional walls begin to crack. Kiara appears overwhelmed, swinging between detachment and sudden bursts of sobbing. She admits that she and her fiancé, Isaac Apodaca, had arguments about Grace staying in their home. She makes statements that suggest Isaac might have planted ideas in her head about Grace.

Viewers of this interrogation witness the psychological unraveling of a suspect under pressure. Every pause, contradiction, and flash of emotion paints a clearer picture of what might have happened—but also leaves lingering doubts.

WHO WAS GRACE JENNINGS?

Grace Jennings, the victim in this case, was just 21 years old. She had been staying with Kiara and Isaac in the weeks leading up to her death. Friends described her as kind and full of life, but possibly struggling with issues that had led her to temporarily stay at the home of McCulley and Apodaca.

Why Grace was targeted remains a key question. In the interrogation video, Kiara seems conflicted—at times remorseful, at other times numb. She hints that there was tension between her and Grace over space, respect, and relationships, but nothing that could reasonably lead to murder.

The tragedy of this case is amplified by the fact that all three individuals involved—victim, suspect, and alleged accomplice—were young adults with entire lives ahead of them. One life was violently ended, another destroyed by guilt and legal consequences, and a third possibly hiding in the shadows of responsibility.

WAS ISAAC APODACA INVOLVED?

One of the most controversial elements of this case is the role of Isaac Apodaca, Kiara McCulley’s fiancé at the time. Kiara suggests in her interview that Isaac manipulated her, possibly influenced her thoughts, and even made cryptic statements about Grace being a “problem.”

Police investigated Isaac thoroughly, but determining his level of involvement was complicated. There were no direct eyewitnesses to the murder itself, and while Kiara mentioned Isaac during her interview, she also seemed uncertain about whether he was physically present during the attack.

Despite the ambiguity, prosecutors took Kiara’s cooperation into account. She ultimately accepted a plea deal and testified against Isaac in exchange for a reduced sentence. Apodaca was later charged with conspiracy in connection with the murder, though his involvement continues to be debated in court and public opinion.

LEGAL PROCEEDINGS AND SENTENCING OUTCOME

Kiara McCulley initially faced a charge of first-degree murder. However, after months of legal negotiation and her decision to cooperate with the prosecution, she accepted a plea agreement. Under the deal, Kiara pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and agreed to testify against Isaac Apodaca.

She was sentenced to 21 years in the New Mexico Department of Corrections, with time served credited. Her plea deal shocked some, who believed the gruesome nature of the crime warranted life imprisonment, while others saw it as a strategic decision by the District Attorney to ensure conviction and testimony against Apodaca.

Isaac Apodaca’s case is still progressing through the legal system. As of now, he is charged but has not yet been convicted of direct involvement in the murder.

PSYCHOLOGICAL PROFILE: WHAT DROVE KIARA MCCULLEY?

Kiara McCulley’s behavior throughout the case raised serious questions about her mental health. Friends and family have described her as having struggled with mental illness, though specific diagnoses have not been publicly confirmed.

Her statements during interrogation swing wildly between moments of clarity and confusion. She often hesitates before answering simple questions and offers contradictory recollections of events. Experts speculate that she may have experienced a psychological break, or was under extreme influence from a dominant partner.

Understanding the full psychological profile of Kiara McCulley may take years. For now, the footage offers a chilling window into the mind of someone accused of one of the most violent murders in Santa Fe’s history.

THE IMPACT ON THE COMMUNITY AND TRUE CRIME VIEWERS

This case sent shockwaves through the Santa Fe community. The idea that such a savage murder could occur in a relatively quiet neighborhood—and involve such young individuals—left residents disturbed and grieving.

True crime communities have followed the McCulley case closely, analyzing body language in the interrogation footage, speculating on motive, and questioning whether justice has been fully served.

The uncut video content, including the full interrogation with her mother and detailed police investigation footage, offers transparency and raw insight into real criminal justice procedures. For viewers interested in real bodycam footage, uncut interrogations, and deep-dive homicide analysis, the McCulley case is as compelling as it is disturbing.

A CASE THAT STILL HAUNTS

Santa Fe Sword Murder – The homicide of Grace Jennings by Kiara McCulley remains one of the most haunting cases in recent Santa Fe history. With layers of psychological complexity, alleged manipulation, and unanswered questions about outside involvement, this is not a crime that is easily forgotten. As more footage and details emerge, true crime enthusiasts and investigators alike continue to examine the evidence and debate whether justice has been fully achieved.

SUBSCRIBE TO REAL CRIME VIDEOS FOR FULL BODYCAM INVESTIGATIONS

If you want full, raw, and unfiltered access to shocking police bodycam investigations, subscribe now to Real Crime Videos on YouTube. Our channel doesn’t just show you edited highlights—we post the full DUI arrest videos, full-length interrogations, and real-time police interactions so you can witness every detail as it happened. From the shocking to the surreal, Real Crime Videos gives you the closest look at America’s criminal justice system in action. Don’t miss future uploads that deliver the truth—uncut, unfiltered, and uncensored.

Kiara McCulley Homicide Interrogation, Santa Fe Sword Murder

Kiara McCulley Homicide Interrogation, Santa Fe Sword Murder

Kiara McCulley Homicide Interrogation, Santa Fe Sword Murder

Kiara McCulley Homicide Interrogation, Santa Fe Sword Murder